to
Featured
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A-Z
Name: Z-A
14 Products

2 Year Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
A versatile cheddar that has a supple texture and delicate flavors of fresh cream and buttered toast. It is perfect for breakfast with preserves or melted as part of your favorite dish. Pair with fresh berries, wheat beers, and sparkling wines.$18.00
Beer Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
This classic Vermont cheddar is washed in Fiddle Head Brewing company's flagship IPA! Sharp and with the hoppy and yeasty flavors from the beer, this one is perfect for snacking and pairing with nuts and beer!$16.99
Clothbound Cheddar Reserve / Cabot
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar / Black Label$34.00/lb
Coastal Cheddar / Ford Farms
Deliciously sweet, yet crunchy and sharp aged British cheddar.$9.00
Hot Pepper Cheddar / Plymouth Cheese
Hot and spicy cheddar blended with habanero and jalapeno peppers from an artisan producer of Vermont cheeses$15.00
Maple Smoked Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
Grafton’s Maple Smoked Cheddar has a mild, buttery body with heady aromas of campfire and smoked ham. A sweet finish recalls memories of toasted marshmallows.$10.99
Original Plymouth / Plymouth Cheese
Original Plymouth granular cheese is handmade with raw whole milk. With a similar taste and texture to cheddar, this signature cheese offers a full-bodied, sharp flavor rounded out with notes of butter, fruit and nuts. Traditionally hand-waxed, enjoy this cheese revived using the original Coolidge recipe from over 125 years ago.$15.00
Prairie Breeze / Milton Creamery
Prairie Breeze is an award-winning, aged white cheddar-style cheese from Milton Creamery in Iowa, known for its unique sweet, nutty, and tangy flavor with hints of pineapple and almond, a crumbly yet creamy texture, and crunchy calcium lactate crystals.$22.00/lb
Private Stock Cheddar / Old Quebec
Old Quebec 10-Year Aged Cheddar is a premium, award-winning Canadian white cheddar known for its intense sharpness, crumbly texture, and complex, lingering flavor with hints of caramel.$24.00
Reserve Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
This Vermont cheddar from Grafton Village Cheese Co. is aged two years, for that sharp, salty, and crystalline bite. The ideal picnic cheese, casual snacking with a refinement about it.$16.00
Smoked Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
This award winning 6 Month Cheddar is hickory wood cold smoked for six hours to give it a subtly sweet, bacon-like flavor that is pleasing to the palate without overpowering it.$19.99
2 Year Reserve Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
Grafton's flagship raw milk cheddar aged for two full years, developing complex flavors with crystalline texture. This award-winning cheddar showcases the perfect balance of sharp, nutty notes with a rich, satisfying finish.$13.00
Goat Cheddar / La Clare Family Farm
This classic Cheddar recipe is made from whole pasteurized goat milk. It has a fresh, fruity, light flavor with a creamy body. Great for snacking or to pair with medium bodied red wines!$25.00/lb
Bloody Good Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
$9.00