to
Featured
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A-Z
Name: Z-A
60 Products

1655 Gruyere / Le Cret
a prestigious, cave-aged Swiss Gruyère AOP and has rich, nutty, and complex flavors with notes of caramel, toasted nuts, and fruit, balanced by a creamy, dense texture with tiny crystals. The "1655" designation signifies a cheese made with strict adherence to traditional methods, often aged 12-14 months, and is considered a benchmark for quality, making it excellent for fondue, gratins, or cheese boards.$36.00/lb
24 Month Comte / Rivoire-Jacquemin
This Comte is made by one of the oldest producers of this variety of cheese in the world. The Rivoire and Jacquemin families have been working together to craft the finest version of Comte you can try. Aged 24 months, this cheese has a full, developed flavor and a gorgeous, slightly crystalline texture.$38.00/lb
Alp Blossom / Hofkäserei Kraus
Made in the Bavarian Alps, Alp Blossom is a fragrant, flavorful, lively expression of its native Alpine flora. After aging, the cheese is bathed in dried herbs and colorful flowers from the surrounding meadows. A beefy, umami paste is juxtaposed with a sweet and floral rind.$40.00/lb
Challerhocker / Käserei Tufertschwil
A unique take on classic Appenzeller, Challerhocker is a raw cow's milk Alpine cheese that is bursting with flavor. Brine washed and made with cooked curds, this cheese is nutty, salty, strong on the nose and absolutely decadent on the pallette.$38.00/lb
Comte / Marcel Petite
When selecting Comté, the Marcel Petite cellar Master considers four key criteria: Delicacy, subtlety, intensity and depth of flavor. The ripening age is an indicator, but not the main criterion of selection. This aged 18 months, and has all the wonderful qualities of the very best Comtes.$40.00/lb
Kaltbach Le Cremeux / Emmi
Often, when a cheese is called cave aged, it is actually aged in a cellar. Not so for Kaltbach Le Cremeux! In 1953, cheesemakers from Lucerne found a winding network of 22 million year old sandstone caves and realized it would be the perfect place to age cheese. The humidity from the river that runs through the natural cave system allows the flavors to become deep and nutty through long aging, while remaining perfectly soft in texture.$40.00/lb
Knockout! / Güntensperger Dairy
Knockout! is a beautiful, full fat Alpine cheese that was created on accident and we're so glad it was. Rich, nutty, and perfectly salty, this one is a real treat.$32.00/lb
Shadow Blossom / Hofkäserei Kraus
Starting from a traditional Allgäu semi-hard cheese, they coat the rind with Wild Madagascar pepper, Long Pepper, tailed pepper, kampot pepper, pink berries and cardamom. Pleasantly soft and crunchy in texture, creamy and buttery in taste, with the kick and complex flavors of six different pepper varieties!$42.00/lb
Piave Vecchio / Lattebusche
Piave Vecchio is produced in the mountains of northern Italy, and is aged for a full year. Made with cow's milk, the finished cheese has a deep and full flavor, with notes of almond and a very long finish. Perfect for grating over pastas and polentas, or sliced with charcuterie.$30.00/lb
Raclette / Livradois
This Raclette cheese from Savoy, has a thin, brownish-orange colored rind, and a yellow-ivory creamy texture. It has a strong and very aromatic taste with a milky, fruity aroma and a sweet taste. It's made with thermalized cows milk, which means it's not heated up as much as pasteurized.$25.00/lb
Red Witch / Kasserei Oberli
A raw cow's milk cheese that is classically Alpine in style, but with a twist! The outside of this cheese is washed with a paprika brine before being carefully aged for 5-8 months, resulting in a supple paste with a complex yet mild flavor, made more vibrant by the paprika. A long time shop favorite, come down to try it!$35.00/lb
Rupert / Woodlawn Creamery
Rupert is an Alpine-style cheese from Vermont made with raw cow's milk. Nutty, sweet, and salty, it's a highly versatile and accessible cheese that’s both sharp and sweet, with complexity and character that only increase over time.$35.00/lb
Ossau Iraty / Rudolph Le Meunier
Ossau Iraty has a distinctive appearance with a natural, brushed, and rustic rind. The interior of the cheese is firm and smooth, ranging from ivory to pale yellow. The flavor profile is rich and complex, featuring nutty, fruity, and sometimes floral notes.$42.00/lb
Chebris / Onetik
A portmanteau of the French words for goat (chevre) and sheep (brebis), this cheese is a stunner. Semi firm and made in the Pyrenees region, you'll get a zesty, lemony palette with a rich and creamy finish.$40.00/lb
Gabietou / Herve Mons
Gabietou comes from Pau in the Pyrenees region of France. It is a semi-soft cheese made with a blend of raw cow's and sheep's milks. It is aged for 3-5 months, during which time the rind is washed with a water and salt brine. A beautiful texture with a deep, earthy, slightly nutty flavor makes for a truly special cheese.$40.00/lb
P'Tit Basque / Istara
P'Tit Basque is a semi-hard, creamy sheep's milk cheese from the French Pyrenees, and has a sweet, nutty flavor and smooth texture.$42.00/lb
Caspian / Jasper Hill
Caspian from Jasper Hill Farm is a raw-milk natural-rind tomme inspired by the funky Savoie-style cheeses of Eastern France, given an American twist by the cheesemakers at Jasper Hill. Cave-aged in the underground Cellars; earthy, mushroomy, and deeply satisfying — the farmhouse cheese that tastes like the Northeast Kingdom landscape it comes from.$35.00/lb
Tomme Basque Vache / Onetik
A cow's milk Tomme from the Basque region of France, Tomme Basque Vache is your new favorite pairing cheese. It has a semi-firm texture and mild yet complex flavors of butter and fresh cream, with floral notes and toasted nut aromas. This cheese is aged for 2.5 months and has a natural rind, and goes with pretty much anything you'd like to enjoy with it. 4.5Kg$26.00/lb
Tomme Brulee / Rodolphe Le Meunier
Starting as a classic Petit Basque (a hard farmhouse sheep’s cheese made in France’s southern Basque region), Tomme Brulee is aged for a few months, and then the rind is burned with an open flame! The result is a beautiful cheese inside and out; everything we love from traditional farmhouse cheeses (grassy and sweet) yet with an added richness from the open flame (caramel-y, smoky, and nutty)$40.00/lb
Ossau Iraty Black Head Manech / Agour
Ossau Iraty has a distinctive appearance with a natural, brushed, and rustic rind. The interior of the cheese is firm and smooth, ranging from ivory to pale yellow. The flavor profile is rich and complex, featuring nutty, fruity, and sometimes floral notes.$40.00/lb
Ossau Iraty / Onetik
Ossau Iraty has a distinctive appearance with a natural, brushed, and rustic rind. The interior of the cheese is firm and smooth, ranging from ivory to pale yellow. The flavor profile is rich and complex, featuring nutty, fruity, and sometimes floral notes.
2 Year Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
A versatile cheddar that has a supple texture and delicate flavors of fresh cream and buttered toast. It is perfect for breakfast with preserves or melted as part of your favorite dish. Pair with fresh berries, wheat beers, and sparkling wines.$18.00
Beer Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
This classic Vermont cheddar is washed in Fiddle Head Brewing company's flagship IPA! Sharp and with the hoppy and yeasty flavors from the beer, this one is perfect for snacking and pairing with nuts and beer!$16.99
Clothbound Cheddar Reserve / Cabot
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar / Black Label$34.00/lb
Coastal Cheddar / Ford Farms
Deliciously sweet, yet crunchy and sharp aged British cheddar.$9.00
Hot Pepper Cheddar / Plymouth Cheese
Hot and spicy cheddar blended with habanero and jalapeno peppers from an artisan producer of Vermont cheeses$15.00
Maple Smoked Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
Grafton’s Maple Smoked Cheddar has a mild, buttery body with heady aromas of campfire and smoked ham. A sweet finish recalls memories of toasted marshmallows.$10.99
Original Plymouth / Plymouth Cheese
Original Plymouth granular cheese is handmade with raw whole milk. With a similar taste and texture to cheddar, this signature cheese offers a full-bodied, sharp flavor rounded out with notes of butter, fruit and nuts. Traditionally hand-waxed, enjoy this cheese revived using the original Coolidge recipe from over 125 years ago.$15.00
Prairie Breeze / Milton Creamery
Prairie Breeze is an award-winning, aged white cheddar-style cheese from Milton Creamery in Iowa, known for its unique sweet, nutty, and tangy flavor with hints of pineapple and almond, a crumbly yet creamy texture, and crunchy calcium lactate crystals.$22.00/lb
Private Stock Cheddar / Old Quebec
Old Quebec 10-Year Aged Cheddar is a premium, award-winning Canadian white cheddar known for its intense sharpness, crumbly texture, and complex, lingering flavor with hints of caramel.$24.00
Reserve Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
This Vermont cheddar from Grafton Village Cheese Co. is aged two years, for that sharp, salty, and crystalline bite. The ideal picnic cheese, casual snacking with a refinement about it.$16.00
Smoked Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
This award winning 6 Month Cheddar is hickory wood cold smoked for six hours to give it a subtly sweet, bacon-like flavor that is pleasing to the palate without overpowering it.$19.99
2 Year Reserve Cheddar / Grafton Village Cheese Co.
Grafton's flagship raw milk cheddar aged for two full years, developing complex flavors with crystalline texture. This award-winning cheddar showcases the perfect balance of sharp, nutty notes with a rich, satisfying finish.$13.00
Goat Cheddar / La Clare Family Farm
This classic Cheddar recipe is made from whole pasteurized goat milk. It has a fresh, fruity, light flavor with a creamy body. Great for snacking or to pair with medium bodied red wines!$25.00/lb
Bloody Good Cheddar / Shelburne Farms
$9.00
Lillian / Parish Hill
Lillian is a mixed cow and sheep's milk cheese from Parish Hill up in Vermont. She is lovingly washed in a Belgian quadruple ale and aged at least three months. The resultant cheese has a light, feathery, and melty texture, with a bright and complex flavor that is sure to have you coming back for more. Pair with hard cider or local beer!$40.00/lb
Wilde Field / High Lawn Farm
Wilde Field is a tasty pressed curd cheese made with pure Jersey cows' milk. Sharp & nutty; complex on the tongue with a bold bite of roasted coffee beans upfront, and a mellow sweetness in the finish. Firm and crumbly yet surprisingly creamy. Aged for over a year, the rind is washed in a locally made Hazy IPA from Antimony Brewing in Lenox to impart subtle flavors of wheat, hops, and citrus.$33.00/lb
Chemin Hatley / Fromagerie La Station
Chemin Hatley is a farm-certified organic cheese. Its firm rind is ripened between three to eight months on wood boards, and the paste yields of floral, fruit and almond aromas. Simply a well done cow's milk cheese; no fuss but still impressive!$33.00/lb
Cornerstone / Parish Hill
Cornerstone is more of a collaborative project than your typical American-made cheese. Three farms, Parish Hill of Vermont, Birch Run Hills Farm of Pennsylvania and Cato Corner Farm of Connecticut all have used the exact same recipe with strict parameters around aging and ingredients, but all use milk from their own herds and their own native cultures. This results in a cheese that very deliberately reflects the terroir of the producers, making it clear how place impacts the final taste. Our Cornerstone is from Parish Hill, and is made with raw cow's milk. The paste is buttery and smooth, with mild yogurt-y flavors that are complemented by a rich nuttiness. Try this piece of cheese history today!$40.00/lb
Oxbow / Woodlawn Creamery
A gorgeous, raw milk cheese from Vermont that is perfect for the cooler weather. A young cow's milk cheese that is lightly smoked with applewood, it is melty, mild, and perfect for cheese nights around the campfire.$30.00/lb
Double Cream Gouda / Cheeseland
Double Cream Gouda is a young Gouda from the Netherlands that is perfect for melting in a cheese sauce or just snacking on. Kiddo tested and approved!$19.00/lb
Pittig Gouda / Cheeseland
Pittig Gouda is a 4 year aged Gouda. Our oldest Gouda here at the shop, this has the characteristic tyrosine crystals, and notes of caramel and toffee on the palette. Approachable and absolutely delicious!$20.00/lb
Parèggio / Artikaas
Parèggio is an Italian Gouda-style cheese that is packed with flavor. It has butterscotch notes that you appreciate in an aged gouda, as well as crunchy, sharp, and nutty flavors you expect from a high- quality parmesan.$20.00/lb
Honey Bee Goat Gouda / Cheeseland
Made with a drizzle of honey added to pure goat milk for a cashew-like nutty sweetness. Slightly sweet, full of flavor, yet not strong or salty. Easy to slice, grate or cube, wonderful in salads or as a snack with fruit.$27.00/lb
Brabander Gouda / Fromagerie L'Amuse
A beautiful goat's milk gouda from Holland! Hand selected by legendary cheese monger Betty Kostner, the Brabander gouda is aged only 6-9 months and combines the creamy, buttery texture of Gouda with the subtle tang of goat's milk, developing rich notes of caramel, hazelnut, and sweet cream, with a smooth, dense, and buttery paste.$36.00/lb
OG Kristal / Kaasboerderij ‘T Groendal
This 22 month aged gouda has it all: rich creamy texture with a fudgy, perfectly balanced butterscotch sweetness, and large, well-formed crystals that pop like candy in bite after bite.$40.00/lb
Roxanne / Oakland Farm
Roxanne is a New England original, hailing from Maine and made on Oakland Farm in Gardiner. The cheese is a cow's milk cheese aged around 4 months and rubbed with sumac and olive oil. The result is a bright, pudgy young cheese with a dijon-y bite.$32.00/lb
Finger Lakes Gold / Lively Run Dairy
Lively Run Dairy's award-winning goat's milk hard cheese, aged 10-12 months. A bit sharp, with a milky, nutty taste.$40.00/lb
Midnight Moon / Cyprus Grove
A gorgeous aged goat's milk gouda that is aged six months or more, Midnight Moon is a blushing, ivory-colored cheese that’s nutty and brown buttery up front with a long caramel finish. As Midnight Moon ages, protein crystals form and lend a slight crunch to the otherwise dense and smooth cheese.$18.00
Smoked Gouda / Smith's Country
A stellar, natural hickory-smoked Gouda made right here in Massachusetts! Made with raw cow's milk, this cheese boasts a mild smokey flavor and a decadent, creamy texture. Excellent for snacking and even as a dessert cheese with some Port wine.$21.00
Essex Brabander Reserve Gouda / Fromagerie L'Amuse
Brabander Reserve, famously nicknamed "Black Betty," is a rare, seasonal goat's milk Gouda hand-selected by master affineur Betty Koster and imported exclusively by Essex St. Cheese. Aged for at least 16 months in unique warm cellars, the cheese develops a dense, crumbly texture heavily studded with crunchy protein crystals. Its complex flavor profile offers deeply sweet and savory notes of caramel, brown butter, and toasted almonds, completely lacking the sharp tang of younger goat cheeses.$46.00/lb
Grated Parmesan / Milano's
Grated Imported Parmesan aged over 10 months.$6.00
Parmesan Reggiano / Giorgio Cravero
Simply put, the best Parmigiano that exists. Incredibly snackable. Crafted by hand from milk of cows that graze in the high elevation of Benedello di Pavulo in Emilia-Romagna, wheels are then aged by Giorgio Cravero, a 5th generation affineur, in a cave at his home in Piemonte.$45.00/lb
Pecorino Romano / Fulvi
Genuine Fulvi Pecorino Romano is a top-rated, authentic PDO sheep's milk cheese from Lazio, Italy, produced by the Sini family in Nepi. Aged 10–12 months, this cheese uses full-fat milk, resulting in a less dry, creamy texture and a rich, sharp flavor that is less salty than Sardinian alternatives.$35.00/lb
Moliterno al Tartufo / Central Formaggi
This cheese is made from pasteurized sheep’s milk and aged for two months before being injected with ground black truffles that infuse the paste with bold, rich flavor and a striking veined appearance.$40.00/lb
Grana Padano / Ambrosi
A classic cow's milk cheese that originates in$28.00/lb
Grated Parmesan / BelGioioso
Grated Parmesan imported from Italy! For giving your easy weeknight meals a boost.$6.00
Drunken Goat / Mitica
A semi-firm goat's milk cheese from Spain washed in grape must, a byproduct of the winemaking process. Easy going and crowd pleasing, beautiful on boards, especially when paired with Spanish red wines.$33.00/lb
Manchego / La Queseria Artesana
Manchego 8 month$28.00/lb
Manchego / Plaza de Espana
A classic Manchego, aged 6 months. Made from 100% sheep's milk, this cheese is bright, punchy, super nutty, and pairs perfectly with Rioja wines and Marcona almonds!$28.00/lb