Moses Reaper is a (monster) mash-up of impeccably made cheese and playful Halloween fun. Jasper Hill puts a spooky spin on beloved, brie-like Moses Sleeper by adding annatto to the silky interior, turning it a festive shade of orange. The rind has a gray tinge thanks to vegetable ash, but the classic flavors of Moses Sleeper remain: button mushroom, fresh milk, and a slight eggy funk.